Your Complete Guide
Choosing the right roofing material is one of the most important decisions you'll make for your home. We break down every major option so you can make a confident, informed choice.
Material Guide

Every Major Roofing Material, Explained

From the most affordable to the most prestigious — here's what you need to know about each roofing type before you decide.
Asphalt shingle roof on a suburban home
Best Value

Most Popular

Asphalt Shingles

Lifespan

20–30 years

Most Popular

Asphalt Shingles

The go-to choice for most American homeowners

Lifespan

20–30 years

Cost

$

Upkeep

Low

Asphalt shingles are the most widely installed roofing material in North America, and for good reason. They strike the ideal balance of affordability, durability, and visual variety. Available in three-tab and architectural (dimensional) styles, they come in hundreds of colors and profiles to match virtually any home.

Pros

  • Most affordable option upfront
  • Huge variety of colors and styles
  • Easy and fast to install
  • Compatible with most roof pitches
  • Widely available contractor support

Cons

  • Shorter lifespan than premium materials
  • Less eco-friendly (petroleum-based)
  • Can be susceptible to algae growth

Best for: Most residential homes

Get a Quote
Standing seam metal roof on a modern home
Longest Lasting

Growing Fast

Metal Roofing

Lifespan

40–70 years

Growing Fast

Metal Roofing

Long-lasting, energy-efficient, and storm-resilient

Lifespan

40–70 years

Cost

$$$

Upkeep

Very Low

Metal roofing has surged in popularity over the past decade as homeowners prioritize longevity and energy efficiency. Available as standing seam panels or metal shingles that mimic traditional materials, metal roofs are engineered to withstand extreme weather while reflecting solar heat to reduce cooling costs.

Pros

  • Exceptional longevity — often outlasts the home
  • Highly resistant to wind, fire, and hail
  • Reflects solar heat, lowering energy bills
  • Lightweight compared to tile or slate
  • Eco-friendly — often contains recycled content

Cons

  • Higher upfront cost
  • Can be noisy in heavy rain without insulation
  • Expansion and contraction over time

Best for: Long-term investment properties

Get a Quote
Clay tile roof on a Mediterranean-style home

Classic Elegance

Clay & Concrete Tile

Lifespan

50+ years

Classic Elegance

Clay & Concrete Tile

Timeless style with outstanding durability

Lifespan

50+ years

Cost

$$$

Upkeep

Low

Clay and concrete tile roofs are synonymous with Mediterranean, Spanish, and Southwestern architecture — but their appeal extends far beyond style. These tiles are non-combustible, impervious to rot and insects, and can withstand decades of harsh sun without fading. Concrete tile offers similar performance at a lower price point.

Pros

  • Exceptional lifespan — 50+ years
  • Non-combustible and fire resistant
  • Excellent thermal performance
  • Immune to rot and insect damage
  • Adds significant curb appeal and value

Cons

  • Very heavy — may require structural reinforcement
  • Higher installation cost
  • Individual tiles can crack under foot traffic

Best for: Mediterranean & Southwestern homes

Get a Quote
Commercial flat roof with TPO membrane

Commercial Standard

Flat & Low-Slope Roofing

Lifespan

15–30 years

Commercial Standard

Flat & Low-Slope Roofing

TPO, EPDM, and modified bitumen systems

Lifespan

15–30 years

Cost

$$

Upkeep

Moderate

Flat and low-slope roofing systems are the standard for commercial buildings, modern architecture, and many mid-century homes. Modern flat roofing uses single-ply membranes like TPO and EPDM, or modified bitumen systems, to create a continuous waterproof barrier. When properly installed and maintained, these systems deliver excellent performance at a competitive cost.

Pros

  • Cost-effective for large areas
  • Usable rooftop space for HVAC and solar
  • Relatively easy to inspect and repair
  • TPO is highly energy-efficient
  • Ideal for commercial applications

Cons

  • Requires regular maintenance and inspection
  • Prone to ponding water if not properly graded
  • Shorter lifespan than steep-slope options

Best for: Commercial & modern flat-roof homes

Get a Quote
Natural slate roof on a historic home
Premium

Premium Tier

Natural Slate

Lifespan

75–150+ years

Premium Tier

Natural Slate

The pinnacle of roofing craftsmanship

Lifespan

75–150+ years

Cost

$$$$

Upkeep

Low

Natural slate is the most premium roofing material available — a genuine stone product that has been quarried and hand-split for centuries. A properly installed slate roof can last 100 years or more, making it truly a once-in-a-lifetime investment. Its distinctive texture and rich color variation create a look that simply cannot be replicated by synthetic alternatives.

Pros

  • Extraordinary lifespan — 100+ years possible
  • Unmatched natural beauty and character
  • Completely fireproof
  • Resistant to mold, mildew, and insects
  • Increases property value significantly

Cons

  • Highest upfront cost of any roofing material
  • Extremely heavy — structural engineering required
  • Requires specialist installers
  • Fragile underfoot during maintenance

Best for: Historic & luxury homes

Get a Quote
Cedar shake roof on a craftsman-style home

Natural Beauty

Cedar Shake & Wood Shingles

Lifespan

20–40 years

Natural Beauty

Cedar Shake & Wood Shingles

Rustic warmth with natural insulating properties

Lifespan

20–40 years

Cost

$$$

Upkeep

High

Cedar shake and wood shingles bring a warm, organic aesthetic that no synthetic material fully replicates. Hand-split cedar shakes have a rugged, textured appearance while sawn wood shingles offer a more refined look. Cedar naturally resists insects and has excellent insulating properties, but requires regular maintenance in humid climates to prevent moss, mold, and rot.

Pros

  • Distinctive natural beauty and warmth
  • Natural insulating properties
  • Biodegradable and eco-friendly
  • Ages beautifully to a silver-grey patina
  • Good wind resistance when properly installed

Cons

  • Requires regular cleaning and treatment
  • Susceptible to moss, mold, and rot in wet climates
  • Higher maintenance cost over time
  • Some fire codes restrict use without treatment

Best for: Craftsman, cottage & rustic styles

Get a Quote
Side by Side

Quick Comparison

A snapshot of how each material stacks up across the most important factors.
Material Lifespan Cost Maintenance Weight Fire Rating
Asphalt20–30 yrs$LowLightClass A
Metal40–70 yrs$$$Very LowLightClass A
Clay/Concrete Tile50+ yrs$$$LowHeavyClass A
Flat (TPO/EPDM)15–30 yrs$$ModerateLightClass A
Natural Slate75–150+ yrs$$$$LowVery HeavyClass A
Cedar Shake20–40 yrs$$$HighMediumClass B/C
Decision Guide

How to Choose the Right Roof

The best roofing material depends on your unique circumstances. These are the key factors our experts consider when helping homeowners decide.
Your Budget
Asphalt shingles offer the lowest upfront cost. Metal and tile cost more initially but save money over decades. Slate is the highest investment but may outlast two asphalt re-roofs combined.
Architectural Style
Your home's architecture often dictates the best material. Spanish and Mediterranean homes suit clay tile. Craftsman and cottage styles suit cedar shake. Modern or farmhouse designs pair beautifully with metal.
Local Climate
Atlanta's hot, humid summers and occasional severe storms call for materials with strong heat resistance and impact ratings. Metal and architectural asphalt shingles both perform exceptionally well in this climate.
Structural Capacity
Tile, slate, and some metal systems are considerably heavier than asphalt. Before selecting a premium material, your contractor should verify your home's framing can handle the added load — or factor in reinforcement costs.
How Long You Plan to Stay
If you plan to sell in a few years, asphalt may be the most practical choice. If this is your forever home, investing in metal, tile, or slate pays dividends in reduced maintenance and eventual re-roofing costs.
Sustainability Goals
Metal roofing contains significant recycled content and is fully recyclable at end of life. Slate and cedar are natural products. Solar-ready profiles are available in metal and some asphalt lines.

Certified installer for every major roofing material brand

GAFMaster Elite® Certified
Owens CorningPreferred Contractor
CertainTeedSELECT ShingleMaster™
FirestoneBuilding Products
IKOPinnacle Certified
Atlas RoofingProCraft Installer
TAMKOPro Plus Member
Johns ManvilleAuthorized Contractor
HenryAuthorized Applicator
GraceIce & Water Shield
PolyglassCertified Contractor
GAFMaster Elite® Certified
Owens CorningPreferred Contractor
CertainTeedSELECT ShingleMaster™
FirestoneBuilding Products
IKOPinnacle Certified
Atlas RoofingProCraft Installer
TAMKOPro Plus Member
Johns ManvilleAuthorized Contractor
HenryAuthorized Applicator
GraceIce & Water Shield
PolyglassCertified Contractor
GAFMaster Elite® Certified
Owens CorningPreferred Contractor
CertainTeedSELECT ShingleMaster™
FirestoneBuilding Products
IKOPinnacle Certified
Atlas RoofingProCraft Installer
TAMKOPro Plus Member
Johns ManvilleAuthorized Contractor
HenryAuthorized Applicator
GraceIce & Water Shield
PolyglassCertified Contractor
GAFMaster Elite® Certified
Owens CorningPreferred Contractor
CertainTeedSELECT ShingleMaster™
FirestoneBuilding Products
IKOPinnacle Certified
Atlas RoofingProCraft Installer
TAMKOPro Plus Member
Johns ManvilleAuthorized Contractor
HenryAuthorized Applicator
GraceIce & Water Shield
PolyglassCertified Contractor
Why Keystone Roofing

We Install Every Material

Most contractors specialize in one or two materials. Our team is trained and certified to install all major roofing systems — so your recommendation is based on what's right for your home, not what's easiest for us.

Certified for All Systems

GAF Master Elite, Owens Corning Preferred, metal roofing certified, and flat-roof membrane trained.

Honest Recommendations

We will tell you which material makes the most sense for your home, budget, and goals — even if it is the cheaper option.

Itemized Estimates

Every estimate breaks down labor, materials, disposal, and warranty so you can compare apples to apples.

10-Year Workmanship Warranty

Regardless of which material you choose, every installation we perform is backed by our workmanship guarantee.

View Our Services

Not Sure Which to Choose?

Let Our Experts Help You Decide

Book a free roof inspection and consultation. We'll assess your existing roof, walk you through the best material options for your home and budget, and give you a transparent estimate — no pressure.

Keystone Roofing consultant reviewing roofing options with homeowner
Get Started

Request Your Free Estimate

Fill out the form below and we'll get back to you within 24 hours — or call us anytime for immediate assistance.
This is a demo site
This website was built by Topography Digital as a demonstration. All contact details are fictional. To get in touch with us directly, email hello@topography.digital.

Get in Touch

Let's Start Your Roofing Project

Reach out anytime — our team is ready to help with a free inspection, honest estimate, and expert guidance.

Phone

(555) 123-4567

Email

hello@topography.digital

Address

1 Fake Street, Nowhere XX 00000

Hours

Mon – Sat: 7AM – 7PM · Sun: Emergency only

Free Estimate

Get Your Free Estimate

Fill out the form and we'll respond within 24 hours with a detailed, no-obligation, transparent quote for your project.

Licensed & InsuredInfo Never Shared24hr Response